Buffalo Nickels Could Be Worth Thousands — How To Spot One

buffalo nickel sits in front coin stack_iStock-160143412

Buffalo nickels are nostalgic coins that were in circulation from 1913 until 1938. Once a regular discovery in everyday life, these coins are now valued antiquities from a bygone period. They were formerly only pocket change, but because of their rising rarity, they are now valuable artifacts with historical (and maybe even monetary) significance.

Explore: 8 Rare Coins You Should Not Spend

Find: 15 Valuable American Coins and Which US States To Find Them

In the past, the excitement of finding a Buffalo nickel was like finding a tiny bit of history, and collectors and enthusiasts still experience that pleasure today. Buffalo nickel collectors often look beyond the famous 1937-D 3-leg nickel and recognize the value of other notable pieces in the series.

One of the finest examples is a nickel obverse 1916 P double die, which has sold for between $66,000 and $281,750 due to a rare die anomaly. The 1924-S Buffalo Nickel is another highly sought after item. It is produced in small batches, and typically costs between $2,500 and $4,000. The 1919-D Buffalo Nickel has an estimated value of approximately $1,713, but its widespread use makes the high-quality nickel difficult to obtain. These coins are highly sought after in the collector’s market because each one has a unique minting history and historical significance.

Buffalo nickels’ value is determined by a number of important characteristics, including their rarity, condition and minting faults. Experts point out that a coin’s age and condition have a big influence on its value. Older nickels — especially those with minting errors — are among the most expensive. In general, mint-condition nickels are worth more than those in less desirable condition.

When determining the coin’s worth, its condition is quite important. Coins in a fair state — with most features worn away but the date and outlines still visible — are less valued than those in a mint state (MS-AU), which shows almost no wear.

A coin’s value might rise significantly due to mint mistakes. Typical mistakes include “Doubled Die Reverse,” “8 Over 7,” “3 or 3 ½ Legs,” and “4 Over 3” make these coins highly collectible and valuable, depending on the production date. These insights from experts shed light on what makes certain Buffalo Nickels particularly valuable and sought after by collectors.

Collectors use the date, mintmark and condition to determine the value of Buffalo Nickels. The main criteria for grading should be wear and detail clarity. These coins should be handled carefully and kept out of direct sunlight. It is best to handle them while wearing gloves to prevent skin oils from corroding them.

According to expert analysis, the most valuable Buffalo nickels are usually those with minting errors in mint condition. Given that almost all error coins are now recycled before leaving the mint, the few that make it into circulation are becoming increasingly collectible and valuable.

Projecting their future value, we can expect that such rare Buffalo nickels, especially those with noted minting errors, will continue to escalate in value. This trend is likely to be driven by their scarcity and the growing demand among collectors for unique and historically significant coins. As the market for these specific types of coins tightens, their prices are anticipated to rise, reflecting their rarity and the collectors’ willingness to invest in these unique pieces of numismatic history.

These coins offer a unique blend of historical intrigue and financial promise. For those embarking on the journey of coin collecting, Buffalo nickels represent a fascinating starting point. Whether driven by passion for history or the allure of investment, collecting these iconic pieces promises a rewarding experience, blending the thrill of discovery with the prospect of appreciating value over time.

More From GOBankingRates

This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: Buffalo Nickels Could Be Worth Thousands — How To Spot One