- Home
- Blame...
Blame Donald Trump for North Korea's saber-rattling
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Russian President Vladimir Putin's recent visit to Pyongyang and North Korea's announcement of tests of new missiles have raised alarms in Washington, rattled America's allies and threatened to destabilize the Indo-Pacific region. While this certainly is not the first time that tensions have escalated, the current turmoil can be traced back to the actions of one man: former United States president Donald Trump.
During his presidency, Trump's attempts at diplomacy were often viewed as ill-informed and dangerous, especially when he and North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un exchanged nuclear threats in 2017. Yet, Trump and Kim, who met for two summits in 2018 and 2019, actually made significant progress toward resolving the decadeslong conflict between their two countries — until Trump's impulsiveness derailed these efforts and set the stage for escalation.
Seeing a chance to shine on the international stage and win a Nobel Peace Prize like his predecessor, Barack Obama, Trump pushed for a summit with Kim. This also reflected a stark reality. In their first and only meeting after Trump's election, Obama warned that North Korea was on the verge of acquiring missiles and bombs capable of killing millions of Americans. Obama also told Trump that the US might have to launch a preemptive strike to prevent this scenario.
Trump's offer to meet Kim was a dream come true for North Korea, signifying its acceptance on the world stage. Kim, like his father and grandfather, sought to modernize the country's underdeveloped economy. Ending the Cold War with the US, which would have enabled North Korea to transfer resources from defense to the civilian economy, was crucial to this process. To achieve this, Kim was even willing to put his nuclear weapons program on the chopping block.
Even as they were issuing public threats, Trump and Kim were secretly angling for a summit. Immediately after Trump took office, the North Koreans reached out to the State Department, signaling Kim's desire to meet the new US president. During secret talks in Singapore, North Korean spies reportedly asked their Central Intelligence Agency counterparts whether Trump was serious about meeting Kim.
Although the Trump administration's official policy was to force the North Koreans to come to the negotiating table, the president liked the idea of a "leader-to-leader" summit. In December 2017, he even provided a United Nations envoy with a message for Kim, proposing a meeting.
Whether Trump knew it or not, engaging directly with Kim was the only way to stop North Korea from amassing more weapons of mass destruction. While observers were dismissive of these efforts, Kim's unilateral decision to halt missile and nuclear weapons tests and start dismantling test sites showed he was serious. Notably, Kim also announced a major economic modernization program, indicating his expectation that the US-North Korea conflict would soon end.
But ending decades of hostility cannot be achieved in a few hours, and the first Trump-Kim summit in June 2018 in Singapore fell far short of such unrealistic expectations. Trump himself seemed to realize this, telling his aides that it was a "process" that might require several summits.
He was right. While Trump was criticized for being unprepared for his second meeting with Kim in Hanoi in February 2019, the summit was preceded by intense negotiations between Trump's special envoy, Stephen Biegun, and his North Korean counterparts. Former US officials said the talks produced a lengthy document that addressed nearly every issue the two countries had struggled with, leaving two major questions for Trump and Kim to resolve: how much of North Korea's nuclear program would be dismantled immediately and how many sanctions the US would lift in return.
Trump and Kim came close to resolving these issues, but Kim's demands exceeded what Trump was willing to offer. The two haggled until Trump, who is known for his impatience, abruptly decided to cut the summit short.
Regrettably, Trump's impulsive decision came just as the negotiations were gaining momentum. After the formal talks had ended, a top Kim adviser approached Biegun with a new, promising proposal. The two seemed to be making progress as Trump walked by, shook Kim's hand, and left despite Kim's request that he stay a few more hours. The American delegation had no choice but to follow Trump, and the stunned Kim returned to Pyongyang empty-handed.
At the time, many experts believed that the summit failed because Kim was not willing to give up his stockpile of nuclear weapons. Some thought that John Bolton, Trump's hawkish national security adviser, had sabotaged the talks, while others noted that Trump was likely distracted by the congressional testimony of his former lawyer, Michael Cohen. But the blame lies squarely with Trump himself. As Anthony Fauci, the former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, put it, Trump's attention span is "a minus number."
Trump himself may have had second thoughts about walking out of the Hanoi summit. As he left Vietnam, he reportedly called South Korea's then-president Moon Jae-in and sought his advice. But Trump and Kim never reconnected.
This raises the question: What if Trump had reached a historic deal with Kim in Hanoi? It is probably safe to say that the US and North Korea would have made significant — albeit slow — progress toward better relations. If they had, it is also likely that Kim would not have jeopardized his new relationship with the US by embracing Putin, nor would he be building an enormous weapons arsenal that threatens to annihilate American cities. Alas, because of Trump's rash decisions, we will never know what could have been.
Joel S. Wit is a distinguished fellow in Northeast Asia security studies at the Henry L. Stimson Center. He is the author of the forthcoming "Flashpoint: The Untold Story of How North Korea Built Its Nuclear Arsenal" (Yale University Press).
Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2024.
- https://www.msn.com/en-ph/news/opinion/blame-donald-trump-for-north-korea-s-saber-rattling/ar-BB1q1olV?ocid=00000000
Related
Alex Eala moves a win away from US Open main draw
MANILA, Philippines — Alex Eala inched a win closer to her first main draw appearance in a Grand Slam tournament as a pro after advancing to the final qualifying round of the US Open. Eala withstood a neck-and-neck duel against Spanish Nuria Parrizas Diaz, 7-5, 7-5, in the US Open second round of qualifiers early Thursday morning (Manila time) in New York. The 19-year-old Filipino bet then battles Elena-Gabriela Ruse of Romania in the final...
NewsTropical cyclone spotted outside PAR
PAGASA is monitoring an active tropical cyclone just outside the Philippine Area of Responsibility as the easterlies continue to affect the eastern part of the country. According to the daily weather forecast on Thursday afternoon, Tropical Storm Shanshan was located at 2,085 kilometers east of Central Luzon at around 3 p.m. The cyclone was slowly moving west, and had maximum sustained winds of 85 kph and gustiness of up to 100 kph. Meanwhile,...
NewsHarry Roque cited for contempt after lying about absence
MANILA, Philippines — Former presidential spokesperson Harry Roque was cited for contempt for lying before the House of Representatives quad-committee regarding the reason for his absence at the first hearing. During the quad-committee hearing on Thursday, Kabayan party-list Rep. Ron Salo showed a certification from Manila Regional Trial Court Clerk of Court Atty. Jennifer dela Cruz-Buendia that stated that Roque did not have a hearing last Aug....
NewsAzrael official trailer
Years after the apocalypse, a devout cult of mute zealots hunts down Azrael (Samara Weaving), a young woman who escaped her own imprisonment.
NewsPBA: Crucial 4-point shot seals San Miguel win over Phoenix
SCHEDULE: 2024 PBA Governors’ Cup elimination round MANILA, Philippines–CJ Perez knocked down a four-point shot that proved to be decisive as San Miguel Beer overcame Phoenix, 111-107, to open its Group B assignment in the PBA Governors’ Cup Wednesday at Smart Araneta Coliseum. Perez made the 27-foot attempt with the shot clock about to expire and the time down to less than a minute as the Beermen extended their lead to five that also helped...
NewsDuterte urged again to attend House probe amid new ‘serious’ allegations
MANILA, Philippines — Former President Rodrigo Duterte was again urged to attend the House of Representatives quad-committee hearing after a hitman claimed that he ordered the killing of three Chinese nationals in August 2016. At the second hearing of the four-panel body on Thursday, Senior Deputy Speaker and Pampanga 3rd District Rep. Aurelio Gonzales Jr. asked that Duterte be invited to the next session so that his side will be heard regarding...
NewsTerranova salvor eyes to siphon 200K liters of oil seawater mixture daily over next 14 days
MANILA, PPhilippines — The contracted salvor for the sunken MT Terranova said on Thursday that it aimed to siphon a total of 200,000 liters of oil-seawater mixture daily from the 1.4 million liters of industrial fuel oil (IFO) cargo on board the ill-fated vessel. According to Harbor Star Shipping Services Inc., they are targeting the completion of the process in 14 days. So far, an estimated 10,000 liters of oil has been siphoned from the ship...
News2 PDLs claim ex-Pres. Duterte ordered them to kill Chinese drug convicts
Two persons deprived of liberty (PDL) on Thursday said they killed three Chinese individuals convicted of drug charges on the orders of former President Rodrigo Duterte. The PDLs, identified as Fernando Magdadaro and Leopoldo Tan Jr. made the claim during a House probe on Thursday. Both Magdadaro and Tan said that back when they were still detained in the Davao Prison and Penal Farm in 2016, police officials asked them to kill the three Chinese...
News